Azier the Swordsman wrote:Romance: I can't believe that people are wasting breath commenting about the scenes with Anakin and Padme.... aren't virtually ALL Hollywood romance scenes corny and unrealistic? You expected this one to be different?
Mr. SmartyPants wrote:natalie portman... shes dumb too... the story was excellent i will say, and i LOVED when James Earl Jones spoke....
Bobtheduck wrote:I also kept your comment about JEJ in there, since I found his few lines in RotS to be... Well, not all that great...
Azier the Swordsman wrote:I find this thread disturbing..... This was such an awesome movie on so many levels: yet all of you seem to want to do is nitpick at 'the acting, the dialogue, plotholes, and other stuff' when it doesn't really matter in the first place. Since when is ANY movie perfect? I think this one is unfairly getting more flak because it's such a famous series. I love the entire saga. I could take any movie, and video game, any anime, and I could type up a huge list of the flaws in each and every one, and they wouldn't be any longer or shorter than Ep 3. Or 1 or 2 for that matter.
I did not think the acting was corny, nor did it even cross my mind that any of the dialogue was 'bad'. Again, I feel as if alot of people are trying to find ways to judge it. I don't really understand why some people can't just enjoy something for what it is rather than making a 21 PAGE THREAD AND COUNTING where 90% of the posts are dedicated to picking it apart?
It's just a movie, people.
Azier the Swordsman wrote:This was, for me, one of the most moving films I have ever seen... I almost cried at the end when Anakin burst into flames, and was later shown being transformed to the Vader we know today.
That alone made the film believable and emotional for me because I have seen the exact same the happen to Christians. It is possible for a strong Christian to become deceived by the lies of the Enemy and fall into darkness, away from God, and destroy their lives.
NOOOOO!!!!!: I thought the scene was very appropriate..... when Anakin realizes the horror that he has fallen into and the agony of losing the one he cared about most, did you really expect him to be silent?
Mangafanatic wrote:The whole Vader scene didn't really connect with me, honestly. I think it's because they didn't use Hayden's voice, so it just felt weird. Plus, it just looked sort of dumb. I agree with Kae that there was definitely a more appropriate physical display of suffering than the one in the movie.
I almost cried through the whole fight between Obi-wan and Anakin, but it didn't really have anything to do with the movie. With that said, I can't really comment on the emotional impact of the film.
Yojimbo wrote:Looked dumb? I fail to see that even remotely. Probably one of the coolest scenes in the movie.
he hasn't yet completely become the Vader we know from 4, 5 and 6 in which he has become completely emotionless and coldhearted
My favorite line:
"Obi wan says you've.. turned to the dark side.."
Lehn wrote:That fight scene between Yoda and DS in the senate chamber... whoa...
His little peg leg touched the lava and then his entire body and face caught on fire as if Obi-Wan doused him with lighter fluid earlier
mean sure a few lines here and there, but poeple started poking at the WHOLE script, as if every sentense was the written by a 4 year old.
AnimeHeretic wrote:Well, from what I understand from lava, the heat can cause things to burst into flame as they reach that temperature (don't leave your pickaxe planted next to a lava stream unless you want it to burst into flame according to some geologist. Since he wasn't moving I suppose the heat built up enough that his body ignited-- I guess the question would be whether he'd die of the heat before he ignited...
Shatterheart wrote:I thought the same thing...it actually kinda suprised me how things went down. In a good way I suppose.
Ashley wrote:I remember being a kid and reading some "ultimate guide to the star wars universe" where it DID say he fell into the lava pits during a fight with Obi-Wan. So yeah, I was suprised too. My theory was that he fell but caught himself or something. I suppose this works too, though. The moment I heard "volcanic planet" I KNEW what was going to happen. And it made me sad.
Return to General Entertainment
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 175 guests