Bio_Plus wrote:I don't see Applejack as the type that would be bothered what others think of her or hated her
But it really is the real reason. This is why the ponies aren't always perfect representations of their elements. If AJ was always honest, no matter what, we would have had an episode where she sent a telegram saying "I'm sorry, I lost the rodeo, but I have a part-time job to make the money for the town hall repairs, and won't be back in Ponyville." And everyone would go "Oh okay" and life would go on as usual.
They can, but most of them haven't. Lyra's canon name is "Heartstrings," and I'm pretty sure Vinyl's is officially DJ PON-3 based on the Equestria Girls song. Also, Carrot Top's official name is Golden Harvest. I've been keeping up with a lot of the canon name complaints.
Well the only reason she's called that is because of drinking that punch in Call of the Cutie. And the fact that she's always drunk. Oh Berry Punch, will you ever be sober?
I also don't see how Berryshine can be your favorite background pony when she's never appeared in an episode to my knowledge at least. I've only seen a couple of other ponies with Berry Punch's cutie mark and none of them were unicorns or the right color.
Bio_Plus wrote:So then what would make Applejack be dishonest?
Actually the blind bag names doesn't equal canon, after all they got Trixie's name wrong.
For me Berryshine = [SIZE="1"]Berry Punch[/SIZE]. Oh so you're going to hold that Rarity recolour against me now
The fandom comes, sees her drinking from a punch bowl and makes her a drunkard. What!?:stressed: Why!?:bang:
And please tell me where she's always drunk? I would like to go and look at that and then fabricate a story to defend her. :pant: :pant:
I really don't like it when people put less-than-innocent attributes on ponies, like drunkenness and (worst of all) sexual innuendo or lesbian "shipping".
Felix (post: 1529381) wrote: Me, I really don't like it when people put less-than-innocent attributes on ponies, like drunkenness and (worst of all) sexual innuendo or lesbian "shipping". I guess you get that kind of stuff from the fans of pretty much any innocent show, but it still really bothers me. I don't like that kind of stuff anyway, but when it's applied to ponies, it's extra offensive somehow. One big reason this show is so great is because of its charming innocence.
" wrote:"Hey look everybody! The punch has been...Spiked!" :p
" wrote:When is she ever not drunk? That's the better question!
I won't argue with that. Although the fandom isn't much bothered by the blindbag names. Lyra has become Lyra Heartstrings in the fandom and I've seen more people using Golden Harvest lately, but on the other hand Blues and Colgate has mostly stayed with their fanon names.More canon than the fan names at least.
Hidden Berry is best background pony.Yes, Berry Punch isn't a unicorn. :p Even if you were to consider blind bag canon, Berryshine is a unicorn.
Bio_Plus (post: 1529473) wrote: And Twister980 oc/Dash is best shipping.
Tigerchu (post: 1529496) wrote:What's wrong with My Little Pony?
Felix wrote:I checked just about every appearance of her that I could find listed, and she doesn't appear the slightest bit drunk in a single one of them. I mean, how could she have won the Sisterhooves Social if she was drunk?
But it is worth mentioning that the creators of the show have commented that there isn't much contact between them and Hasbro's toy division (I believe it was Jayson who commented on that) and they don't have much say to what the toy division does, which could mean that fanon names are still up for grabs.
" wrote:Did I miss anything?
I was actually talking about things that would go wrong with the ponies, stuff that would ruin their day. But never mind, Cake Assault defeats my point.I'd say all those things are what's right with it! And in that case, you forgot loads of stuff. Like, just about everything else. Cake being used as a weapon? Genius.
I wouldn't say it's anime style, but I can see what you're getting at.I just see it as "My Little Ponies" in an anime style.
Felix wrote:I don't really like it when they start dragging the show down to a much lower level
" wrote:Wait, how is the fandom ever going to drag the show down?
Return to General Entertainment
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 46 guests