Page 1 of 2

W Juliet

PostPosted: Thu May 19, 2005 10:30 pm
by Hoshika
This manga is so sweet. I've only read a little thanks to the lovely lady of this site; http://dear.to/wjuliet . I can't believe anyone would give this cute little manga a bad review.

PostPosted: Mon May 23, 2005 8:37 pm
by VioletEyedCat
Hoshika wrote:This manga is so sweet. I've only read a little thanks to the lovely lady of this site]http://dear.to/wjuliet[/url] . I can't believe anyone would give this cute little manga a bad review.


AAAAAAAA!!!!!! I can't believe I was offline when a historic post like this was made! I LOVE W-Juliet (as is obvious by my avatar) and I own the first three volumes that have finally been published in the US. I own up to volume 7 from scanlations on-line. W-Juliet is seriously awesome. Yeah...so, I had to get that out of my system. :sweat:

PostPosted: Mon May 23, 2005 9:01 pm
by Yeito
Is it really that good? Someone told me it was like... yuri. But I guess not huh? I'll have to look at it when i'm at the store tomorrow. o.o;

PostPosted: Mon May 23, 2005 9:16 pm
by Alice
I'd love to hear a detailed review of this, if any of you get the chance.

It might be one I read a few pages from in a magazine.

If so I'd like to check it out again, (if it's any good).

:) Sorry for the disjointed thoughts. :)

PostPosted: Tue May 24, 2005 2:06 am
by Hoshika
[quote="Yeito"]Is it really that good? Someone told me it was like... yuri. But I guess not huh? I'll have to look at it when i'm at the store tomorrow. o.o]

Y-y-yuri!? No, not even close... well there is this one girl who is too obsessed with the main female character but she is represented as an annoyance and utter nucance.

BTW: VioletEyedCat, love your ava! Rock on!. :D

I have vols. 1-4 if I can I'll post more about it without giving up any major spoilers. :D

PostPosted: Tue May 24, 2005 11:27 am
by Jasdero
sldkfjlkjf XD Yay! I only just discovered W Juliet three days ago. >:3 I bought W Juliet vol.4 in a store, and then vols. 1-3 off the internet. o.o They will arrive today, as a matter of fact. XD;;;; I hope... this isn't a typical shoujo manga (boy chase girl, girl chase boy, boy and girl chase other boys and girls, boy and girl get back together, boy and girl fall apart again, etc... etc....). It doesn't seem that way...
[quote="Yeito"]Is it really that good? Someone told me it was like... yuri. But I guess not huh? I'll have to look at it when i'm at the store tomorrow. o.o]
o__o;;; Absolutely not. XD lol, I think they thought it because:
[spoiler]Makoto has to pretend to be a girl for reasons you'll find out yourself when you read vol.1 ^__^[/spoiler]
Soo..... under those circumstances o.o *tears the yuri theory to shreds* XD No worries.

PostPosted: Tue May 24, 2005 1:30 pm
by Doubleshadow
Good! I wanted to take a look at this series but I had the same previously doubts. Reassuring to know. I'll have to hit the bookstore soon then.

PostPosted: Wed May 25, 2005 7:09 am
by Hoshika
[quote="Sunako"]sldkfjlkjf XD Yay! I only just discovered W Juliet three days ago. >:3 I bought W Juliet vol.4 in a store, and then vols. 1-3 off the internet. o.o They will arrive today, as a matter of fact. XD]


Well, I have to warn you there is a bit of chaing going on but it's so funny. I laughed through vol. 1. But laughing aside it is a very lovey dovey manga and to tell the truth I usually don't read such mush but the story and characters are so well put together and the art is great.... I couldn't help myself!

PostPosted: Wed May 25, 2005 2:07 pm
by Namelessknight
So how is for detail, nudity wise? Cause I read a chapter in some sampler, and really liked it. But with a guy at a girls school pretending to be a girl, I could see how things could really go bad. So, I guess, is it clean?

PostPosted: Wed May 25, 2005 3:42 pm
by Yeito
I'm... sorry? .-. I didn't mean to make ya'll upset. I was just saying what someone told me and thats why I didn't read it. I'll have to try it now though.

(PS: Love you're avatar namelessknight. :) )

PostPosted: Wed May 25, 2005 8:09 pm
by VioletEyedCat
Namelessknight wrote:So how is for detail, nudity wise? Cause I read a chapter in some sampler, and really liked it. But with a guy at a girls school pretending to be a girl, I could see how things could really go bad. So, I guess, is it clean?


I've read throught volume 7 - and the only nudity I can remember is a non-sexual bra shot, which in itself was very chaste. And the thing is...
[SPOILER]it's not even really a bra shot because the main male character, as explained before, has to pretend to be a girl, and wears this body-suit thing to convince the villainesque character that he is a girl[/SPOILER]

The whole series I think is one of the cleanest shoujo's I've come across- I'd recommend it to anyone.

PostPosted: Wed May 25, 2005 8:50 pm
by Alice
Sounds great! I'll definitely look into it. :)

PostPosted: Wed May 25, 2005 9:11 pm
by Jasdero
Yeito wrote:I'm... sorry? .-. I didn't mean to make ya'll upset. I was just saying what someone told me and thats why I didn't read it. I'll have to try it now though.

o.o You didn't upset us -- not me, anyway. XD;;; I think I might have wondered the same thing if I had just seen a few panels from it and not known the full story. ^^;;;;

PostPosted: Wed May 25, 2005 9:17 pm
by Alice
Will someone please tell me what XD means??

PostPosted: Wed May 25, 2005 9:18 pm
by Jasdero
Alice wrote:Will someone please tell me what XD means??

XD!

XD = laugh.

X = closed eyes.
D = open mouth

PostPosted: Wed May 25, 2005 9:22 pm
by Alice
Oh... thanks. :)

Still sounds kinda strange to me, but thanks for explaining it! Now I'll know what everyone means when they say it... Maybe.

PostPosted: Wed May 25, 2005 10:01 pm
by Hoshika
Namelessknight wrote:So how is for detail, nudity wise? Cause I read a chapter in some sampler, and really liked it. But with a guy at a girls school pretending to be a girl, I could see how things could really go bad. So, I guess, is it clean?


LOL, He doesn't go to an all girls' school. Though he can pull off the look Makoto is a little careless and if he went to an all girl's school he would have been caught in no time flat. Stil he is no where near as careless as the girl in Hana-Kimi. I might have to take off my socks to count how many people know about her little secret, good thing they all want to watch out for her.

Um well, yes. The nudity in W Juliet. I haven't seen anything beyond Makoto with his shirt off (or in a bikini). And that boy stays pretty covered up for the most part, from the head down. If it isn't a wig he has on it's a hat.


[spoiler]This one girl does assault him and rips his shirt off in order to prove that the new female transfer student is really a boy but upon tearing open his shirt she was shocked to find he had breats which totally threw her off. Good thing she didn't take a better look to see if they were fake.[/spoiler]

Yeito wrote:I'm... sorry? .-. I didn't mean to make ya'll upset. I was just saying what someone told me and thats why I didn't read it. I'll have to try it now though.

(PS: Love you're avatar namelessknight. :) )



LOL, don't worry Yeito I wasn't angry with you and I don't think anyone else was. I'm suspecious of most T rated manga especially since a lot of the shounen ai stuff and yaoi mess is getting published in the U.S. in droves, not to ignore the high rate of hentai stuff that keeps finding it's way to the States. It's always better to ask questions and be safe rather than sorry.

PostPosted: Fri May 27, 2005 2:44 pm
by Namelessknight
Yeito wrote:(PS: Love you're avatar namelessknight. :) )


thankyou :)[unfortunately, as you can see, it has changed now :)]

and thanks others for all the info. I will definitely be looking into getting this, once i actually get some money[stupid TRSI sales!]

PostPosted: Fri May 27, 2005 4:14 pm
by Alice
What is TRSI?

I, also, am looking into buying W Juliet now. ^-^

So, thanks everyone!

PostPosted: Fri May 27, 2005 7:08 pm
by Yeito
Sorry Sunako and Hoshika. I wasn't trying to accuse you of being mad. -_-; I'm sorry.

I agree with you Hoshika. There is way too much yaoi and hentai stuff gettin licensed/published. I understand that in Japanese culture its not really a big deal, but that doesn't mean that america has to go gaa-gaa over it. -_-

Sorry. I'm really tired. r_r;

PostPosted: Fri May 27, 2005 7:38 pm
by Namelessknight
Alice wrote:What is TRSI?
!



The RightStuf International, online seller of anime, manga, etc. [url=rightstuf.com]TRSI[/url]

PostPosted: Sat May 28, 2005 3:35 am
by Hoshika
[quote="Yeito"]Sorry Sunako and Hoshika. I wasn't trying to accuse you of being mad. -_-]


:poke: Hey! You're apologizing for nothing! It's easy to misunderstand things over the net, but make no mistake I'm not mad atcha.... so just take my acts of random violence as love taps. :hug: I'm not the passive aggressive type by no means. ^_^

LOL, I don't know about it being more acceptable in Japan but people there just don't hide the fact they are perverted. Hence all the "Love Hotels" you may pass by in Tokyo. >.<

Is it just me or does anyone else want to strangle Makoto? Yeah Ito is a bit hot headed but he just keeps giving her reasons to stay boiling.

PostPosted: Sat May 28, 2005 10:39 am
by Yeito
Well... the reason I said it was more 'acceptable' in Japan was I read a book on Japanese culture and it said that while its not like 'oh well they're gay.. whatever...' They just don't see it as big of a deal as we do. ... Am I making any sense? <.<;

Its kind of like how they have co-ed baths there. Its just... not that big of a deal. Cause they're culture is different than ours. o.o;

I'll be quiet now -x-; ........ Sorry.

PostPosted: Sat May 28, 2005 5:49 pm
by Mangafanatic
Alot of Gender Benders weird me out (Girl Got Game), but then again, others don't bother me at all (Hana Kimi :rock: ) so I really should just go ahead and give this a try!

Thanks for the info guys and gals!

PostPosted: Sun May 29, 2005 8:26 am
by Hoshika
[quote="Yeito"]Well... the reason I said it was more 'acceptable' in Japan was I read a book on Japanese culture and it said that while its not like 'oh well they're gay.. whatever...' They just don't see it as big of a deal as we do. ... Am I making any sense? <.<]

*Grabs Yeito and puts her in a head lock* Unless you do something like that... :lickbash: QUIT SAYING YOU'RE SORRY!

Anyway, I think we are on the same page as far as the perversion is concerned.
As for the unisex bathes.... :wow!: co-ed bathes? Huh? I know they have bath houses were men and women go but there are dividing walls and if so inclined a pervy peeper can climb up the wall and look down at the other side. ... I'm a J-fan to the core so I'll PM you to talk more about this so not to take attention away from the main topic:

Who thinks Makoto or Ito is a real hottie?

As for Mangafanatic, hehehe, welcome to the fold. :lol:

PostPosted: Mon May 30, 2005 7:18 pm
by Yeito
I'm sor---.....

I mean i didn't mean....

*sigh* I can't help that I apologize alot -x-; . Everyone always tells me that I do. ;-; I'm sor... <.< *sigh*

I'm not saying I'm sorry cause I think you're mad. I say it cause... cause... cause... <.<; >.>; Uhm. I... don't know? .-.;

PostPosted: Mon May 30, 2005 8:46 pm
by Hoshika
LOL, I'm not angry. I'm just violent. Bwahahahaha. ^o^ (Like that sounds any better. -_-') You are who you are and you talk the way you talk. It just seemed like you were blaming yourself needlessly.

There is a city in Japan where a lot of homosexuals gravatate for some reason, maybe cause the people's attitudes there are more accepting of it.. kinda like a city in the U.S.

Reading the third vol. of W Juliet I started to feel sorry for Makoto.

[spoiler]Having another boy chasing after him and getting all red in the fae at the thought of sharing the same hotspring water with him. Makoto seemed a bit annoyed, but that's what happens when you go around tricking people into thinking you're woman when you're not. Still, the kid must have rocks for brains even after Makoto told him he was in a relationship he still chases him. :p [/spoiler]

PostPosted: Tue May 31, 2005 6:01 pm
by Yeito
o_o I went to the store... and they dont have WJuliet any more. Someone bought it all.... :waah!:

PostPosted: Tue May 31, 2005 6:36 pm
by Hoshika
There there, you can always special order it.

How far have you gotten in the series so far?

PostPosted: Wed Jun 01, 2005 11:55 am
by Yeito
Uhm. none. -_- you guys made it sound so good and i went to check it out and it was all gone. *sigh* I'm sorry. (_ _)