Shadowalker (post: 1190512) wrote:I don't see why you say that. We're saying almost the same thing. We're both saying that Saturday is the traditional Sabbath.
The only difference between us is that you say...
... to which I say, well, this is clearly not the case amongst Christians.
Almost all Christians I know consider Sunday to be "the Lord's Day" - we go to church on Sunday, not Saturday. To many Christians, "keeping the Sabbath" translates into attending church on Sunday, and perhaps abstaining from shopping, and/or engaging in prayer/Bible reading to a greater degree than on weekdays, or Saturdays.
Now, I agree with you that Saturday is the historical Sabbath, and that was never changed by God Himself or anything like that... but the vast majority of Christians have effectively chosen to make Sunday our holy day of the week.
What I'm saying is that this isn't true. See, early Jewish Christians did both. There was no competition between one and the other, as there is no competition between Christmas and Easter. They were completely oriented towards other things.
Other than some exclusive Fundamentalist groups, I can't see any evidence of any Church accepting that the Sabbath Translates to our Worship on Sunday. Sunday was a gathering, usually at a house, not a synagogue.
{if you can show me that there ARE groups that believe this, then I will accept correction gladly}
Shadowalker (post: 1190512) wrote:Exactly. Which is why we think of Sunday as "the Lord's Day", and translate "keeping the Sabbath" as going to church on Sunday, reading the Bible more, etc...
Honestly, I know precious few Christians who attach any religious significance at all to Saturday.
Right, and we'd expect that, as most don't observe the Sabbath at all. From the beginning of the Church, I think it was Clement who said that Jesus was our Sabbath, and every day is our rest, or that our true rest is with him.
Only some, very silly, Christian groups have confused the tradition from 2000 years ago, of the Lord's Day, with the Sabbath.
The reason I said you were wrong at first, is that you said this made the SDA's different from other Fundamentalists. Having debated at length with SDA's, and having been a Fundamentalist previously for many years, I know well that this isn't quite fair. Most Fundamentalists don't consider the Lord's Day to be the Sabbath. It's one of those misunderstandings among common church goers.. just as The descriptions surrounding the birth in Matthew and Luke are assumed to be on the same day, even though they clearly are not, or the assumption that Eve ate an Apple, or that Moses wrote the Pentateuch, or that there were 3 Magi, etc.
These are misconceptions, and they are rarely actually an article of faith for any group, because when people write articles of faith, they study up first.
Shadowalker (post: 1190512) wrote:Well, again, I know precious few Christians who attach any religious significance whatsoever to Saturday. However, almost all Christians I know attack religious significance to Sunday.
That's all that I meant by what I wrote concerning the Sabbath in my reply to Gabriel.
No problem on your reply or anything - just clarifying what I meant.
yeah, I've just got to keep myself on a little bit of a leash here, as apparently discussing theological things leads to debate, which leads to
for the mods. So... yeah. I just felt I'd like to clarify that point.