termyt wrote:I've heard this before, and I'm not saying it isn't true - I have no idea. But, for some reason, I doubt it's veracity. It's true that Roman Catholics would have been persecuted in England since the Church of England was the official religion, but the tenants of both faiths are very similar.
It doesn't seem likely that Catholics would have to vale the message of Christ's birth in such a code as "A Partridge in a Pear Tree" since their neighbors would have been celebrating it as well, only as Anglicans in stead of Catholics.
Like I said, I don't know if the story is true or not, just some food for thought. Hope I didn't rain on anyone's parade.
CDLviking wrote:I also seem to remember that the five golden rings were the five wounds of Christ, which is why that part of the song sticks out from the rest.
ZiP wrote:Excellent, I thought it was just about some dude who liked spoiling his love.
AnimeHeretic wrote:Ah well, I don't know if the story is true or not (I've heard both the story and the rebuttal before), but at least it puts meaning into what would otherwise be a pretty dumb song.
AnimeHeretic wrote:Of course, with the stories in the news about schools forbidding the use of religious oriented Christmas Carols, maybe one with a hidden meaning like this has it's uses hmm?
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 171 guests